Public Policy and the Lottery

Lottery is a state-sponsored game in which players purchase chances to win a prize. The prizes range from a single item to a significant sum of money. Many states use the proceeds from the lottery to provide social services, infrastructure, and education. Some state lotteries are run by private corporations, while others are government-sponsored. In the United States, the majority of state lotteries are run through an organization called the State Lottery Commission.

The casting of lots to determine decisions and fates has a long record in human history, including several instances in the Bible. But the idea of using a lottery for material gain is considerably more recent. The first recorded public lottery was held during the reign of Augustus Caesar to fund municipal repairs in Rome, and the first lottery to distribute prizes was established in 1466 in Bruges (in what is now Belgium) for the declared purpose of aiding the poor.

When modern lotteries were introduced in the early post-World War II era, they were promoted as painless forms of state taxation. They were hailed as “spending without raising taxes.” Politicians and the general public alike saw a way to expand the scope of state services without burdening middle- and working-class taxpayers. By the 1960s, that arrangement began to collapse in the face of inflation and a growing need for social safety net programs. State governments needed more revenue to keep up with their spending, and lottery revenue became the focus of the debate.

Lotteries are a classic case of public policy being made piecemeal and incrementally, with little or no overall overview. Once established, the lotteries are driven by the need to attract bettors and grow revenues. Consequently, they tend to work at cross-purposes with the larger public interest.

A key question that has been largely overlooked is whether it’s appropriate for the state to promote gambling and, if so, what’s the proper role of a lottery commission? Lottery advertising focuses on two messages primarily. The first is that the lottery is a fun experience, and it’s meant to distract from the fact that lotteries are regressive. They pull a large percentage of ticket purchases from low-income neighborhoods.

The second message is that playing the lottery is a civic duty. This is a bit of an outright lie since the vast majority of lottery ticket purchases come from those with more incomes. But it obscures the regressive nature of the industry and obscures how much the lottery relies on people’s willingness to gamble to raise funds for their state. Regardless of their social status, people enjoy gambling and are drawn to the possibility of winning big. As a result, state lotteries are an essential part of the nation’s gambling industry. However, there are a number of problems with the current structure of state lotteries that go beyond their regressivity and fiscal toxicity. To address them, state lawmakers and lottery officials must reconsider their policies.

Back to Top